Vol. XLI,
No. 2
April - June 2006Editorial Note
Essays
Cyprus and the EU: Two Years Later
Security Questions and the Search for a Cyprus Settlement
Hubert Faustmann
Security was the major concern of the
Greek Cypriots when they voted down the "Annan V Plan " in March 2004. Yet, it
can be argued that the strong and historically understandable security concerns of the
Greek Cypriots were exaggerated and that many did not realise how difficult it would be
for Turkey to intervene on the island again after entry into the EU. The article looks
into the concerns of all players involved and provides a list of recommendations should an
amended Annan Plan or a new settlement be designed in the future.
The European Union: What Role in the Cyprus Conflict?
George Christou
With the belief that the EU would act
as a catalyst in the period prior to the accession of the (Greek) Cypriot government to
the European club on 1 May 2004 having ended in disappointment, this article looks at the
more complex internal/external dynamics now at play in the current milieu. A key question
raised is the extent to which the EU can effectively prevent the potential short-term
negative effects emerging as a result of the its failure to realise its objectives for the
north, from crystallising into further developments that could make reunification of the
island impossible. To do this, it will have to exploit the opportunities that exist to
facilitate movement towards reunification, a difficult but not impossible task if the EU
takes into account the demands of all actors involved.
Domestic Politics and External Challengs in
the Middle East
Europe's Role in the Gulf: A Transatlantic Perspective
Roberto Aliboni
The Middle East and the Mediterranean
have never been favourable to strong transatlantic convergence. The subject of terrorism
has always brought to the fore differences between the United States and Europe, first in
the Palestinian-Israeli context, then in the first wave of terrorism unleashed in the
1980s. This difference in assessment of the strategic importance of terrorism reflects on
democracy promotion policies. In the US policy towards the Greater Middle East,
democratisation as a response to terrorism is based on a pessimistic cultural assessment
of the societies concerned. In the European view, democracy promotion plays a pivotal role
in the Mediterranean and the Middle East but is regarded as a long term transformation
requiring a number of cooperative responses on both sides.
Post-Syria Lebanon: Internal and External Determinants of a Crisis
Karam Karam
After the assassination of Rafik Hariri
on 14 February 2005, Lebanese society took to the streets in the "Lebanese
Spring" with a series of demands, including the withdrawal of the Syrian army from
Lebanon and parliamentary elections by June of that year. All demands were met, but during
the election campaign, the old dilemmas of the confessionalised state once again took the
upper hand. Behind these dilemmas are various political crises revealing of structural
problems. The country is still in the throes of an all-engulfing crisis. In order to
contain it, the leaders of the main political forces convened a "conference of
national dialogue" in March 2006 - the first example of inter-Lebanese consultation
without foreign trusteeship since 1975.
Changing Dynamics in Palestinian Politics
Yezid Sayigh
The article analyses both the dynamics
of change affecting the Palestinian political and governing systems and the relationship
between internal structures and processes - such as PA reform - and external ones,
specifically the peace process and relations with Israel and the international community.
A decisive shift has taken place in Palestinian politics. The ascent of Hamas represents a
radical break with the legacy of former PLO Chairman and PA President Arafat and the
political culture of PLO "returnees" who came with him from their Tunisian
exile. Contrary to common perceptions, the success of Hamas in office may be critical for
the deepening of Palestinian democracy and restructuring of good governance.
Opinions
The Dilemma of Aid to
the Palestinian Authority After the Victory of Hamas
Anne Le More
At the beginning of the Oslo process
aid to the Palestinian population was aimed at sustaining the peace endeavour, economic
and social development, and the PA process of nation-building. Hardly any of these
objectives have been achieved as donor funds were gradually shifted to emergency and
humanitarian assistance during the nineties and especially after 2002. This has had many
perverse effects, notably deepening Palestinian dependency on foreign aid, sustaining
Israel's actions in the Occupied Territories and violations of international law, and
diminishing the prospect of a viable two-state solution. Nevertheless, the Quartet's
decision to stop funding the now Hamas-led administration could have potentially
disastrous effects. Therefore, it seems unlikely that donors will use this crisis as an
opportunity to reassess their failed "aid for peace" strategy towards the
Israeli-Palestinian peace process.
The Success of Islamist Parties Works Against al-Qaida
Laura Guazzone
While both are convinced that
"Islam is the solution", Islamists and al-Qaida represent two different views
and political strategies. Islamist parties have militant grassroots participation and
propose respect for the rule of law and concrete political and social projects. Moreover,
the main Arab islamist parties have rejected violence as a means of political struggle.
Hamas obtained the government majority by means of fair and free elections. Al-Qaida,
instead, offers an undefined political platform: the restoration of an Islamic meta-state
through the exhortation to Islamists to join the jihad. The political opportunities
represented by the competition between Islamists and jihadists is well understood by some
Arab regimes but seems to be less well understood in Western countries.
Italian foreign policy survey
Berlusconi's Foreign Policy: Inverting Traditional Priorities
Sergio Romano
In the postwar period, Italy had always
pursued a foreign policy inspired by three essentials: enthusiastic adhesion to the
objective of European union, a solid relationship with the United States, and a privileged
relationship with the Arab countries of the Mediterranean and the Middle East. For a
number of reasons these priorities were inverted under Berlusconi who also took a more
"personal" view of foreign relations. In the end, this course does not seem to
have corresponded to the hopes and expectations of its leader.
Book Review and Notes
The Strategic
Cultures of "Old" and "New" Europe
Paul Luif
IAI Library Notes
Maritza Cricorian