Book Reviews
On Naivety and Tolerance
Cesare Merlini
Review of: Reflections on the revolution in Europe :
immigration, Islam, and the West
/ Christopher Caldwell. - New York [etc.] : Doubleday, 2009. - xii, 363 p.
- ISBN 978-0-385-51826-0
Buy this article online
Hamas at a Crossroads: Taking Stock of Past Experience
(see also a review in Italian)
Silvia Colombo
Review of: Hamas : che cos'è e cosa vuole il
movimento radicale palestinese
/ Paola Caridi. - Milano : Feltrinelli, 2009. - 284 p. - (Serie bianca).
- ISBN 978-88-07-17171-0
Buy this article online
Exploring the Principle of Coherence in EU External Action: A Legal Analysis
Michele Comelli and Federica Di Camillo
Review of: L'azione esterna dell'Unione europea e
il principio della coerenza
/ Alessandra Mignolli. - 2. ed. - Napoli : Jovene, 2009. - xxi, 550 p.
- (Pubblicazioni del Dipartimento di Scienze giuridiche Università
degli studi di Roma "La Sapienza" ; 37). - ISBN 978-88-243-1896-9
Buy this article online
Recent Publications
European studies
The European Neighbourhood Policy and the
Southern Mediterranean / Michele Comelli, Atila Eralp, Çigdem
Üstün (eds). - Ankara : Middle East Technical University Press, 2009. -
xiv, 181 p. - ISBN 978-9944-344-79-1
The countries of the southern shore of the Mediterranean are increasingly
critical of the set of policies that the EU has devised and has been
implementing towards them since the early 1990s. This criticism, together
with recent and not necessarily positive political and economic developments
in the region, have spurred a much required reflection on the EU
Neighbourhood Policy in order to assess its flaws and potential in the new
international context. The book aims at meeting this need by studying the
inter-relationship of EU deepening and widening in the context of
EU-Mediterranean relations and by exploring expectations on both sides.
The rationale of the book is "to analyse the Southern dimension of the
European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP) which, as frequently noted in academic
and policy debates, presents different challenges and opportunities than the
Eastern dimension" (157). The book is composed of seven chapters which
correspond to as many contributions, plus an introduction and some
concluding remarks. It sheds light on the specific content and evolution of
the ENP towards the Southern Mediterranean countries in a way that is easily
accessible to all kinds of readers. It does this by focusing on the
perceptions of Europe's Mediterranean partners and, in particular, on three
case studies (Algeria, Egypt and Israel). Additional analysis is provided
for the cases of Morocco and Jordan in the interesting cost/benefit
assessment of the ENP's potential for reform in the southern Mediterranean
in the political, economic and social arenas (53-77).
The analysis moves easily through the intricacies of the linkages between
enlargement and the ENP's Southern Mediterranean dimension in view of filling
a gap in the literature. In fact, "while there are myriad studies that
enquire into the lessons that the ENP towards Eastern partners can draw from enlargement,
very little has been analysed regarding the lessons that the ENP towards
Southern partners can draw from enlargement, and even less about the role
that Turkey can play in this triangle" (157). This aspect represents a
significant value-added with respect to the many other studies on the
subject. Placing Turkey at the centre of the debate on enlargement and the
ENP is particularly interesting at a time when Turkey is increasingly
playing a central role in the Mediterranean and the Middle East.
What is striking is the absolute homogeneity and sometimes repetitiveness of views
and evaluations that emerge from the different sections of the book. On the
one hand, this reinforces the book's main arguments, for example, that
countries in the various Mediterranean regions tend to share perceptions and
preoccupations with regard to the ENP. On the other, however, it hampers the
book's cohesion of structure. Additionally, analysis oscillates between the
academic and the operational. All in all, the book aptly underscores the
shortcomings of the ENP in the Southern Mediterranean and draws some
relevant policy-oriented conclusions - albeit scattered in its various
sections - providing a useful tool for scholars, EU decision-makers and
officials. (S.C., also in Italian)
L'idea dell'Europa nelle relazioni
internazionali
/ Silvio Fagiolo . - Milano : F. Angeli, c2009. - 250 p. - (Il punto ;
70). - ISBN 978-88-568-0343-3
It is not very often that a thorough analysis of the European integration
process turns into a vivid overview of contemporary history. Furthermore,
the story of Europe from Chabod onwards has been told so many times that it
is difficult to deal with it in an original way. Yet, Fagiolo manages to do
so by setting the extraordinary European adventure in the framework of the
international events that either positively, or more frequently negatively,
conditioned the integration process and determined its further development:
from the end of the Second World War to the rash French-British expedition
to the Suez in 1956; from the emergence of the flexible response doctrine to
the first disarmament negotiations with Moscow; from the beginning of the
Cold War to the fall of the Berlin Wall.
More specifically, the author
spends a lot of time looking at US policies and initiatives towards Europe.
This emphasis on Washington's role serves two purposes: on the one hand, it
puts the transatlantic dimension into the right perspective as the key
factor in explaining the European Union's progress or lack of it in the
economic, political and above all military fields; on the other, it uses the
US federal model as a historical and institutional reference point to
measure the federative nature of the European integration process. And it
becomes evident from the very first pages that, in spite of the Union's
progress in these last fifty or more years of institution building, it still
has a long way to go to match the reference model and very probably never
will.
Silvio Fagiolo considers the failure of the European Defense Community
in 1954 the negative turning point for Europe's ambitions to proceed towards
an American model of federation: "the EDC's failure showed that the
Europeans are not willing to lose that fragment of military sovereignty in
their reciprocal relations that they still possessed after the end of the
second world war".
It is interesting to note that the author considers
the lack of a European military dimension the fundamental difference between
the United States and Europe. Despite the steps taken by the EU in this
field in the last decade, including the most recent decisions to set up
battlegroups (although they have never been deployed) and to launch over
twenty civilian and military missions in the world, there can be no doubt,
as the author puts it: "that Europe does not have that unscrupulous
military capability that the United States has".
Once again, the
fundamental difference between European and American history emerges: for
the latter, "the strategic matrix … is the civil war, the rejection
of proportionality in the fight for survival: war is hell". And since
this is not and never will be the case in Europe, the European Union is, to
use Jeremy Rifkin's definition, a kind of early United States with
confederal characteristics, the heir to an America that disappeared years
ago - "The alternative dream," says Fagiolo, "for those who
have stopped dreaming about America."
In other words, the
"American model" is fading away and is being replaced by a Union
that has never had the courage to go beyond the limits of a
"reinforced" confederation. The thesis, as put forward by someone
who has experienced Europe's difficult history as an insider, is interesting
and brave. It should not be forgotten, as Mario Monti points out in the
introduction, that Silvio Fagiolo is above all an ambassador who had the
privilege of participating first hand in most of the negotiations that
contributed, from the European Single Act onwards, to the deepening of the
European Union's institutional architecture. This is also why Fagiolo
praises and recalls with admiration Roberto Ducci's "anonymous and
unseen but fundamental work of negotiating and drafting the successive
drafts of the initial pact (the Treaty of Rome): not [one of] the makers of
European policy, but [a] craftsm[a]n who behind the scenes laid the premises
and built the scaffolding". (G.B., also in Italian)
The European Union and global governance
/ edited by Mario Telò. - London and New York : Routledge, 2009. - xx, 353
p. - (Routledge/GARNET series: Europe in the world ; 6). - ISBN
978-0-415-46506-9 ; 978-0-203-88366-2 (ebk)
The book is a collection of essays that explore the role of the EU as a
global actor, concerning both regional cooperation and global governance.
Two points of view are adopted: the influence of the EU on the rest of the
world, that is its impact on the multilateral international setting; and its
impact on regional governance, as a model of a two-level polity (the
national and EU dimensions). The EU, the product of the consolidation of
supranational and intergovernmental institutions, is assessed for its
internal successes and failures and its positive and negative influences
externally. The contributors explore the consequences of the EU as a
multi-level and multi-actor power and as a regional and global actor. The
book is divided into three parts: the EU's external impact on global
governance, EU external policies and the EU agenda.
The first section
addresses the EU's ability to export its model, influencing the rest of the
world with its democratic governance, both as far as relations within states
and between states are concerned. The issue is whether the EU can be an
effective international "democratizer". To answer this question,
the contributors focus on the common currency, the common market and EU
socio-economic model. Notwithstanding asymmetries, failures and pending
challenges, the success of these internal achievements has had an influence
on the EU's near (regional) and distant (global) external environment.
The second part of the book looks at the complex legal foundations of EU
external action, underlining how the role played in the international arena
is in part exclusive to the EU and in part shared with member states. It
stresses the lack of coherence due to the different fields of EU action
developed to some extent within the European Community context and to some
extent within the common security and foreign policy. The contributors
critically assess a variety of EU external policies, namely trade - the most
centralised and consolidated - cooperation, the environment, common foreign
and security policy, justice and home affairs.
Part three examines the EU's
role as a global actor, dealing in particular with neighbourhood policies.
It focuses on the complexities the EU has to face with regard to its
regional dimension in the Mediterranean versus its inter-regional role
vis-à-vis partners overseas. The authors analyse the effectiveness of EU
policies, their successes and failures, and their contribution in the global
context, assessing the EU as a political actor. Regional and inter-regional
cooperation policies are reviewed in a historical perspective that takes
account of national colonial policies and EU legacies.
The book offers
several considerations on the regional consequences of the European process
of unification and its spillovers on the global scale. The book's main
thread is the question whether the EU can represent a model for regional
governance and whether its policies can be applied at the international
level. Far from finding a conclusive answer, the book provides different
visions of the future of the interstate system and the challenges to the
EU's role in global governance. (S.Ch.)
Greater Middle East
Nel nome di Omar : rivoluzione, clero e potere
in Iran / Marcella Emiliani, Marco Ranuzzi de' Bianchi, Erika
Atzori. - Bologna : Odoya, c2008. - 351 p. - (Odoya Storia ; 1). - ISBN
978-88-628-8000-8
Understanding the stages that marked Iranian society's path to the 1979
revolution - a unique revolution led by a religious group - represents one
of the best means to understand Iran and its regime today. This
understanding is especially relevant now when, for the first time, a
non-religiously affiliated person has been confirmed as the president.
Nel nome di Omar develops this analysis by delving deeply and broadly into the
historical causes that brought the Iranian religious establishment to engage
in domestic politics and progressively become, through the years, the leader
of the revolution and, later, of the state.
The authors boast a good mix of
knowledge and experience which allows them to cover all aspects of the
issue. Marcella Emiliani is a prominent professor at Bologna University,
with a high-profile academic career and much experience in research on Iran
and the Middle East in general. Marco Ranuzzi de' Bianchi and Erika Atzori
contributed to the work with their recent field work, making the more
academic, historical first part of the book more topical and
reader-friendly.
The book is divided into three parts which deal with three
different time periods: from the clergy evolution that led to the revolution
up to the death of its leader; the revolutionary system without Khomeini and
the difficulties in its management before Ahmadinejad; and Ahmadinejad's
Iran divided between the clergy and the army.
Emiliani's first part presents
the roots of the Iranian clergy's first engagement in politics with the
Tobacco Riots in 1891-92. From there the book proceeds with a careful and
vivid historical analysis of how the feeling of a discontent towards the
Shah spread throughout the country - a country which, as Emiliani clearly
explains, united itself in all its part, nationalists and communists, around
the leadership of the Shiite clergy to express its rage against the regime
of the monarchy. A path that only towards the end became an Islamic
revolution and that can be defined as "a process of reactions, with
different scales of consciousness, against the chaotic forced modernisation
process imposed on Iran".
Ranuzzi de' Bianchi's second part is a very
detailed and precise analysis of the new Islamic Republic's structure and
functioning. Very interesting is the clear account of how, after Khomeini's
death, the Shiite establishment split into factions and fought for the
presidency. In this situation, the most important reforms that the country
needed were not carried out, provoking the reaction of the intellectuals.
Atzori's third part takes us up to the current situation, presenting the
presidency of Ahmadinejad. The analysis of the electoral process that
brought Ahmadinejad to the presidency reveals an interesting
behind-the-scenes view of the different Iranian political fronts. The
in-depth profile of the previous government is very useful in understanding
the major domestic and foreign policy issues that face modern Iran. All of
this prepares us for the description of the political background of the 2009
elections.
Emiliani suggests that in Iran everything seems to be transformed
but not destroyed. The book leaves one wondering whether the recent 2009
elections continued the historical clash of factions that has permeated
recent Iranian political history or whether things might change. (S.Sa.)
La strada per Kabul : la comunità
internazionale e le crisi in Asia centrale
/ Alessandro Minuto Rizzo. - Bologna : Il mulino, c2009. - 183 p. -
(Collana AREL/il Mulino ; 67). - ISBN 978-88-15-12736-5
The author of this book was the Vice Secretary General of NATO from 2001 to
2007. During his term, he interpreted the role with remarkable political and
diplomatic initiative, accompanying and at times anticipating NATO's
progressive deployment out of an area, from the Gulf to Afghanistan.
From his intense work with NATO, the author draws a brief essay dealing with his
trips and his impressions, especially in Central Asia. The account never
loses its sense of proportion nor of the ridiculous which is somehow always
hidden behind the tragic.
The author begins by recalling how the European
press enthusiastically reported the wanderings of a brown bear through the
mountains of Switzerland, Austria and Bavaria, its matings and its destiny,
at the very time when the most serious terrorist attacks were shaking
Afghanistan and Pakistan, the site of a power struggle of global dimensions.
Minuto Rizzo tries to cut through Maya's veil, delicately, almost by
osmosis, to transport us softly into another, little known but not for this
reason strange or, much less, irrelevant reality - a reality in which he is
helped by such great authors of the past as Byron with his The Road to
Oxana and of course Kipling, but also by other less universally known
authors. This erudite and sophisticated view facilitates flashes of
comprehension of a world that is difficult for and in many respects still
unknown to most people and in many ways even to NATO. It is quite beyond the
author's intention to criticize the Alliance, but the author's delicacy in
presenting the subject matter cannot completely hide the surprise of someone
who saw the Alliance engage in Afghanistan without really knowing how and
why. Only in 2006, with the strategic decision to expand its presence in the
south and the east of the country, did NATO enter directly into war with the
Taliban and take on the burden of fighting the drug industry, once again
without correctly and fully assessing the consequences.
Minuto Rizzo describes a confused and progressive "bogging down", which has not
been followed up, perhaps because of the allies' lack of full political
awareness of it, by deployment of the necessary military and economic
resources and a coherent strategic approach (this includes the operations
conducted autonomously by the Pentagon with the forces of Enduring Freedom,
which have always been kept distinct from NATO forces).
But the book goes
beyond this to tell of the Alliance's increasing diplomatic relations in
Asia and the Pacific, from Mongolia to Japan, from Australia to New Zealand.
It also goes into the increasing importance of Pakistan and, therefore,
India and the dispute over Kashmir. Minuto Rizzo is not a pessimist, nor
does he underestimate the important steps that have been taken, in spite of
all the difficulties, in Afghanistan. Nevertheless, he would like to see
more awareness especially on the part of the Europeans. His professional
"envy" for Ahmet Cetin, the Turkish ambassador and former foreign
minister who was NATO's political representative in Kabul and then Turkish
ambassador in Islamabad, is almost tangible. He seems to envy Cetin's
evident understanding of the local leaderships and their rules, and his
connections in almost all directions. This, Rizzo observes, is a result of
the constant and growing attention that Turkey has for Central Asia, in
addition of course to its greater historical, cultural and religious
affinities.
There may be a suggestion in all this. In the future, in order
to exit positively from a crisis and continue to proceed effectively along
the road to greater global governance, it would be useful to understand
better the situations and the countries, the cultures and the ambitions of
the people. Colonialism is dead and buried and it is no longer acceptable to
face tomorrow with the same bag of errors as in the past. (S.Si.,
also in Italian)
Geopolitics
Geopolitica dell'ambiente : sostenibilità,
conflitti e cambiamenti globali
/ Corrado Maria Daclon. - Milano : F. Angeli, c2008. - 255 p. - (Uomo,
ambiente, sviluppo. Saggi e manuali ; 37). - ISBN 978-88-464-9795-6
Although the term geopolitics has recently experienced a resurgence in
academic circles, the literature debate in continental Europe has gradually
dismissed the original focus on the theoretical link between policy and
environment, moving towards a simpler realist understanding of the zero-sum
game aimed at securing the control of resources. In contrast with this
trend, Corrado Maria Daclon's book provides a well-structured review dealing
with the nuanced nature of the geopolitical debate, emphasizing the role of
the environment in security issues, international law and scenario
construction. Indeed, international organisations and security scholars are
progressively transcending the global level of analysis to focus more in
depth on the local level, where geopolitical links emerge and the concept of
distance acquires significance.
In the first chapter, the author touches
upon several academic lines of thought: from the early conceptual steps of
the term "geopolitics", to the deterministic definition by Ratzel
and Haushofer, characterised by an ideological meaning, and from the
Anglo-Saxon theories of Mahan and Mackinder - based on the strategic
interpretation of maps - to the domino theory put forth during the Cold War.
For several decades, these classical geopolitical theories have fascinated
readers thanks to their aesthetic impact, rather than their scientific
value.
From chapter two onwards, the author systematically analyses the
causal influence of the environment on social actions, providing an
explanatory framework for demography, migrations and the factors underlying
them, such as desertification in Africa. The two following sections
encompass a sociological and historical study dealing with the concept of
resources, in accordance with a special focus on strategic energy needs,
from wood to uranium, with oil playing a significant role because of its
multiple industrial uses and the consequent political leverage it gives to
exporting countries.
The fifth chapter deals with environmental policy.
After listing actors and international organisations involved in the field,
Daclon analyses - one by one - the actions undertaken by the US and the EU,
The author also analyses the most significant phases of the sustainable
development effort, from the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate
Change (UNFCC) to the Montreal Conference in 2005. Statistical evidence is
provided to illustrate how contemporary conflicts are influenced by
environmental variables, as shown by the "NATO Science for Peace and
Security Programme", and to point out that the current resource
distribution and migration dynamics are framing a new context for security,
not only at the European but also at the global level. Indeed, European
governments will have to face an increasing number of problems due to
welfare and employment unbalances, while the pivotal area globally for the
environmental question is situated in Central Asia. In Central Asia the
Chinese demand for energy and the Russian supply meet in a complex political
environment, increasingly impacted by the military presence of the US.
The sustainable development question is assessed in the last chapter. Here the
author evaluates the competing schools of thought from Malthus and Reclus to
Gore, whose efforts to improve environmental awareness have brought the
issue to international attention.
Overall, this book sheds light on the
increasing role played by environmental politics in international security
and it provides a multidisciplinary guide, combining legal aspects,
sociological descriptions, scientific forecasts and scenario constructions.
However, because of its synoptic and overarching academic nature, the work's
analytical depth is limited by the intrinsic breadth of the issue itself and
should therefore be conceived as an initial step towards further research. (S.M.)
La partita eurasiatica : geopolitica della
sicurezza tra Occidente e Russia
/ Cristiano Orlando. - Roma : Ediesse, 2009. - 147 p. - (Materiali). -
978-88-230-1351-3
The East-West axis has been the subject of many recent studies and analyses.
The issues of energy security, the future of NATO and the unquestioned role
that China is increasingly playing as a global actor are without a doubt
linked to the strategies revolving around the large area that delimits the
Russian borders. The end of the short-lived idea of US hegemony and the
simultaneous Russian recovery after the post-Soviet crisis has created the
conditions for a scenario defined by some observers as a renewed Cold War.
Others have instead dismissed Moscow's actions as feeble shows of strength
conducted by a somewhat unstable country.
To understand these dynamics,
Cristiano Orlando's book proves extremely useful. Indeed, it provides a
comprehensive view of the players involved, their present geopolitical
condition and their prospects for the future. The persisting transformation
of internal and external balances that Europe and Russia have been
experiencing since the end of the Cold War are described well in the first
chapter, where the author outlines their recent history and their present
conditions. Nor does he overlook the two traits d'union that bind them, the
Balkans and Eastern Europe, whose importance as a passageway for energy
routes is obviously underlined. Particular attention is given to the
progress made in the European integration process and to the Western-driven
dynamics in those countries once under Soviet influence.
The "Euro-Atlantic dimension" is the subject of the second, and
central, section of the volume. NATO's role is challenged more than ever by
its own transformation and its future ability to ensure the coexistence of
the eastward expansion and its relationship with the former Russian
arch-enemy. The book offers an overview of all the major modernisations
undergone by the Alliance in the last two decades, contextualising them into
the larger scenario composed of border areas and countries, often disputed
by the two blocs.
The border areas and countries are the main subjects of
the third and final chapter which illustrates what stakes are in play,
mainly focusing again on energy sources and routes. Thus, Ukraine is
described as the door by which Russian resources can reach Europe, and the
Caucasus (with Georgia as the key factor), the threshold for the pipelines
coming from Central Asia.
A specialist on the subject would probably not
find much more in this book than he already knows, but someone who has never
approached this multi-faceted theatre will probably find Orlando's book an
agile compendium that provides an in-depth analysis on the thin thread
binding the US, Europe and Russia together - a thread that criss-crosses
disputed countries and areas such as the Balkans, the internally divided
Ukraine and the war-torn Caucasus, the strategic importance of which has to
be understood.
The book's structure makes it easy to lose the train of
thought and, thus, the overall picture. Nonetheless, considering the
enormous number of variables and factors involved, this 140-page volume
provides enough data and maps (though the latter could have been of better
quality) to provide a fairly inclusive introduction to this complex topic. (A.C.)
Miscellaneous
L'elefante ha messo le ali : l'India del XXI
secolo
/ Antonio Armellini ; prefazione di Giuliano Amato. - Milano : Egea -
Università Bocconi editore, 2008. - x, 397 p. - (Interazioni). - ISBN
978-88-8350-087-9
In this book, the author, the Italian ambassador in Delhi from 2004 to 2008
and former coworker of Altiero Spinelli and Aldo Moro, tries to explain why
India is a "good bet".
The contradictions that characterise the
Indian Union and that are often incomprehensible for a non-Indian, are not
the result of either fate or chaos, but are rather an expression of the
coexistence of a past that has not been left behind and a future which is
just unfolding. From a political point of view, the Indian democracy is
unique, quite different from the European model. In spite of its numerous
contradictions, the real miracle is that India is the largest experiment of
a functioning democracy in the world.
In Armellini's opinion, the apex of
Indian contradictions lies in the discrepancy between the cities and the
countryside, and above all, the castes. The caste system is, on the one
hand, the ultimate expression of odious and immobile discrimination, but at
the same time, even though this is officially denied, it is an instrument of
social equilibrium and political stability. With universal suffrage and the
creation of elected bodies at the local level, the castes have become the
strongest political pressure groups. The paradox is that representative
democracy, the ultimate expression of Indian modernity, has given new
impulse to the castes, the greatest sign of discrimination and
anti-modernity.
Analysing the instruments for the formation of consensus -
from the media to NGOs, from political parties to civil rights and women's
rights movements - the author touches on the thorny problem of tolerance.
The question is: how will India manage to govern the compatibility between a
market logic and the very idea of democracy that should give breathing room
to profoundly different ethnic and cultural groups.
Armellini reinterprets
the Indian concept of "karma", which no doubt contributes to
explaining the great optimism with which India is expecting to be a great
power player, especially in economic and international relations.
Alternatively, it can also be considered the basis for a kind of arrogance
that is sweeping over the country. An arrogance, as Armellini writes, which
more than any other factor risks falsifying the decision-making processes
and the very ability to assess one's capabilities non-dogmatically. This is
the same arrogance that kept the country in difficult relations with its
neighbours, especially at the regional level, for a long time and which
prevented it from understanding that a regional policy attentive to the
needs of the others and without hegemonic leanings is not an alternative
policy, but the premise for taking on the role of major actor at the world
level. Arrogance is probably also at the root of the scarce flexibility with
which India entered into the negotiations for reform of the United Nations
Security Council and which held up the achievement of a cooperation
agreement with the United States on civilian nuclear power for a long time.
It also conditions the country's behaviour on the Kashmir question, perhaps
the most important from a political-strategic point of view.
The book describes a society that is not growing homogeneously and that seems unable
to come to terms with its contradictions. This contradiction is that India
has an arrogant view of itself that can only be mitigated by recognition of
the importance of its international role. The book also describes a fragile
economy that is being rebalanced, an inefficient and corrupt bureaucracy, a
judiciary that does not effectively enforce the rule of law with a civil
society that is only just starting to become aware of the problem.
The book is clear and useful to both the layman and the specialist. To point out some
shortcomings, however, the issue of the relationship between the caste
system and social stability, while presented in a brilliant and provocative
way, may not be adequately justified. Wanting to take this line of reasoning
to its extreme conclusion, one might say that the mafia has also played the
role of stabilizer in Italian society. But this is certainly not sufficient
reason to believe that these forms of stabilisation are good or, much less,
necessary. (E.P., also in Italian)
Il paese di Obama : come è cambiata l'America
/ Maurizio Molinari. - Roma ; Bari : Laterza, 2009. - xv, 195 p. (I
Robinson. Letture). - ISBN 978-88-420-9104-2
Good morning America
/ Gerardo Greco. - Milano : Sperling & Kupfer, [2009]. - 213 p. -
(Saggi). - ISBN 978-88-200-4708-5
Barack Obama : l'uomo del destino
/ Franco Ferraro. - [S.l.] :
ilmiolibro.it,
2008 (Roma : Gruppo editoriale L'espresso). - 160 p.
Three books compared: a little over a year after Barack Obama's inauguration
as president of the United States, it has become fashionable to write about
the first black man in the White House and "his" America - books
that reflect, albeit in different ways, all the many expectations roused by
the irresistible rise of the senator from Illinois and that do not reflect
President Obama's drop in popularity at home (but not in Europe).
The authors are all journalists who, like correspondents, tell Italians about
Obama's United States and therefore are well acquainted with the American
continent and the Obama "phenomenon". In the titles and the texts
we find the surprise and the enthusiasm of the presidential campaign and the
expectations and hopes for the election and the inauguration, rather than
for the difficulties and problems of the first year in the White House,
looking for ways out of the economic crisis and trying to find the right
path to peace or at least dialogue on such international fronts as Iraq and
Afghanistan, Iran and the Middle East.
Until now, President Obama has not
had the same success as candidate Obama: he still has not convinced his
fellow Americans to fully agree to a health care reform; he has not won the
war for the "hearts and minds" of the Afghans; he has not been
able to involve Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejad in dialogue; nor has he
unblocked the Israeli-Palestinian negotiations. But the President, like the
candidate, remains a symbol of hope, personifying the American dream.
The fact that he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize means that the world still
has confidence in him. Maurizio Molinari tells how the United States changed
(Com'è cambiata l'America) with the advent of Obama. "In
one night," he writes, "we went from George W. Bush to Barack H.
Obama and the world appeared different". The book's eleven chapters
take us on a trip to see the places and meet the people that are building
that new American dream, which is to some extent also our new dream.
Molinari, US correspondent for La Stampa since 2001, is a prolific author
(since 2003 he has published an average of one book per year) and an
attentive and active journalist. In the United States, he has interviewed
great economic and political leaders, told the story of life and politics in
the White House and the places of power in Washington, the Hurricane Katrina
disaster, the Wall Street crisis and the last election campaign.
Gerardo Greco describes his book as a "trip to discover the tracks of the new
American dream". The author, long the RAI 2 News correspondent from New
York, has written about Afghanistan and Iraq, the Bush presidency and
Obama's rise. Greco explains his book with the following words: "After
finding my grandfather's papers and letters, I decided to follow the tracks
of my predecessors. I wanted an American story to tell and, above all, I
wanted to understand whether the American dream still exists. Barack Obama
said that the United States has to recapture that dream and I wanted to find
out what it consists of."
The book by Franco Ferraro is centred more on
the figure of Obama and the campaign that brought him to the White House.
Ferraro, the editor in chief of Sky News and author of the weekly
Seven international news magazine, was in the United States as a
correspondent to follow the Illinois senator's campaign and managed the live
broadcasts of the decisive debates with Republican candidate John McCain.
The book is the story of Obama, but above all it is the story of the 600
days between the announcement of his candidacy for nomination in
Springfield, Illinois, on 10 February 2007, and his victory in the
presidential election on 4 November 2008: "600 days in which,"
writes Ferraro, "Obama, born in 1961 in Honolulu of a Kenyan father and
a white American mother, sweeps away all forecasts and prejudices, silences
the Cassandras and gurus and travels alone towards Pennsylvania
Avenue." (A.M., also in Italian)
Contributions for this issue were received from Gianni Bonvicini,
Alessandro Capocaccia, Sofia Chiarucci, Silvia Colombo,
Simone Mecca, Adriano Metz, Eva Pföstl,
Sebastiano Sali and Stefano Silvestri.